Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Monday, June 4, 2007

WHAT IS MAN?

An existentialist is someone who focuses his or her mind merely in the pursue of his or her sole purpose in the world. Many renowned philosophers define the term existence. Most prominence of these philosophers is Jean Paul Satre. Satre proposed his superb terminology of existence precedes essence. His opinion, human comes to the world without any pre-conception of his purpose in the world. His essence is solely built by his existence. Human define his/her own reality.



Existentialistic view of human reality come in opposition of the traditional believe which has come way back since the Greek era where human existence comes after his or her essence already there. In this believe, human already has a purpose even before he or she exists.

Hard core existentialists such as Satre, Hegel, etc denied the existence of God where as other existentialists such as Paul Tillich, Gabriel Marcel, and Martin Bauber who their existentialism based on Christian theology except the existence of God. However, both atheistic and theological existentialists share the same themes and tenets in their existentialism. The choice of believe or not believe of God is a personal choice.

Apart from atheistic and theological existentialism, the third group is the agnostic where in this side; they do not claim to know or not knowing the ‘great picture’. The existence of God for agnostic is something beyond human comprehension. And because of this reason the pursue of explanation of relation between human and God has little interest for them.

In his Essay In Existentialism, Satre said that if man, as the existentialist conceives him, is indefinable, it is because at first he is nothing. Only afterward he is something, and he himself will have made what he will be. In this sense, it is not God or any other thing will responsible for human action but it is man himself responsible for what he does and become. Later Satre argued that human consciousness is the one which responsible for human action from the choice he made regardless any consequences will follow. Human is condemned of his free choice and he himself will receive the consequence of his choices. Following Satre’s guideline, man could only be what he be when his consciousness leads him to a state where man decision becoming reality.
Consciousness in Satre’s term is a being for-itself where as being for-itself, consciousness may change into what it is not. However, further, Satre divide consciousness into two as positional and non-positional. Positional consciousness will create man awareness of his surrounding because it will put consciousness in relation of its surrounding. In the other hand, non-positional consciousness is only being conscious of man surrounding.

Satre stressed his existentialism in the subjectivity of man since man is the one who form and build his purpose. But he did not deny the objectivity of man where man tend to think of something based on other thought rather than purely rely on his own thought. And this reality creates clash of freedom where one’s being become object of another subjectivity. In this case, although a man is responsible of his own choice, the choice he made is under influence of other’s gaze. And man’s existences become ‘in-itself’ or object rather than the subject of authority.

Read More......

Friday, June 1, 2007

SURPLUS OF MEANING AND EFFECTIVE HISTORY

In philosophy, there are two branches which try to explain the relation between the past and the present/future. They are Paul Ricoeur’s theory of ‘surplus of meaning’ and Hans-Georg Gadamer’s theory of ‘effective history’.


Paul Ricoeur (1913-2005) is a French philosopher and anthropologist. He proposed that the ‘semantics’ career of a text would last longer than its ‘semiotic’ status. A text becomes the trace of the past in the present and future from which people in the present and future can try to experience the past. An event in the past will become a discourse in the future which can represent the past. The ‘surplus of meaning’ of a text arise when the text distanciated from its author and its original context.

Hans-Georg Gadamer (1900-2002) is a German philosopher. He proposed the theory that between the past and the present, a dialogue is exist. The present belongs to the past just like a listener belongs to a speaker. The meaning of the past is not complete without the present. The past continues in the present with an incomplete meaning. The people in the present could see into the past through the text until the limit of the horizon.

After trying to understand Paul Ricouer’s theory of ‘surplus of meaning’ and Hans-Georg Gadamer’s theory of ‘effective history’, I find that what we know as present is the result of the past. The present prepares the ground for the present to exist. However, the past itself will not be complete without the works in the present as Gadamer said in his theory. The continuity of the past depends on the interpretation of the people in the present. The way they interpret works of the past is effected by how they receive their understanding of the past itself.
The works in the present are not merely the repetition of the works of the past but they are the outcome of the present’s creation in interpreting the past. Through time, the meaning of works of the past keep on folded and folded. The ability of the present to re-create the meaning of the past is also folded by the modification of tradition passed from generation to generation.
When we observed the work of the past, we try to re-create the meaning of the object observed and try to re-define the meaning of it. The result of the re-creation and re-definition in the present will never be the same as the result created by the people before us because the atmosphere of the re-creation and re-definition is different.

As the past does not bring its complete meaning itself to the present, it will never appeared completely to the future of it because the effort to re-create and redefine the work will never recovered the true meaning of the work. The result of these efforts will always be the modification of meaning which will prepare the ground for the future works.
In the other hand, the present itself will not be complete without the work of the past because without the past, the present will not have its root in our consciousness. This root is important to state the position of the work of the present in our consciousness. The present is the reflection of the past but it is not like our reflection in the mirror; the reflection of the past in the present is distorted by the modification of tradition.

Read More......

T.S ELLIOT AND TRADITION

No poet, no artist of any art has his complete meaning alone. This literary observation is proposed by T.S. Elliot in his essay ‘Tradition and The Individual Talent’ published in 1917. Tradition, according to Elliot, is a price of great labour. People in the present do not have tradition just like that but they have to gain it with the effort to understand the tradition itself. Tradition is something that passes down toward generation boldly because each generation will try to learn and understand the tradition from they has in their historical sense.

Elliot described in his observation that in any work of art, there must be the trace of the work in the past. And also to analyze a work of art, we should put it side by side with the work from the past. We do this thing not to judge which one of them better than the other but to compare and to contrast one to another aesthetically because from the very beginning there is already a structural order of art in every culture. The aesthetic value of a poem which we try to compare and contrast is purely about the poem itself, not then life of the poet.
The work of art in the present is only the continuation of the existing order of art. If we try to measure the work of art without the previous work, we could not find the real value of that work because the value of a work of art is in its position in the simultaneous order of art in tradition. The work of a poet in the present contains the poet’s appreciation toward the works of the earlier poet. This appreciation is the result of the poet’s historical sense. The historical sense which the poet has is not only deal with the pastness of the past but also the presence of the past in the present. The historical sense of the artist is the result of his knowledge upon the work of artists in the past and his experience in his youth period.
The poet could takes he past as his standpoint in creating his work. The poet should be aware that the order never changes; the existence of the art itself never changes but the material to build the art always changing. An artist should always aware that he should become the part of this order; he will never stand alone as an individual in art. That is why an artist should have a good knowledge about this order, about artists who came before him. He should sacrifice himself, his personality to acquire his position in this order.
The good criticism of art should always put the work of art as the main point of analysis in its criticism, not the artist’s life. A good work of art will always apart from the artist’s life. The artist should be able to create his work as his manifestation of his observation. The better the artist, the more he depersonalizes his work. The good criticism will show the work in the present’s position in the existing order of art. The good criticism will try to find the race of the work in the past in the work of the present.
The mind of the artist just becomes the media to produce the creativity of art without making any obvious influence in it. In his mind, an artist will treat the emotion he discovers from external world to transfer in his work. The work of art is the artist’s creativity to materialize his observation toward the world. The emotion that he put in the work is not his personal emotion but it is the emotion that he extracts from the outer world. If an artist able to gather more emotion in his work, the work will be better. He artist should be able to arrange and organize the emotion in his work to make it more artistic.

Read More......

PHENOMENOLOGY OF READING

Phenomenology is the study of phenomena in which ‘phenomena’ refers to things as they appear in our experience, or the ways we experience things, thus the meanings of things have in our experience. Phenomenology studies conscious experience as experienced from the object of the experience. Phenomenology is a branch of philosophy which studies consciousness as a result of human intuitive experience toward any object of their life. Phenomenology puts the intuitive experience of phenomena as its basic of analysis and tries to find the essential features of experience and the essence of what has been experienced by human beings.


Edmund Husserl (1859-1938) was considered as the founding father of phenomenology. He was the pupil of Franz Brentano (1837-1917) and Carl Stumpf (1848-1936). The main concept which had given by Husserl was ‘intentionality’ which explains the relationship between mental acts and external world. This term describes that the main characteristic of consciousness is that it is intentional. The way it is directed through its content or meaning toward a certain object in the world. He borrowed the term ‘intentionality’ from his mentor, the philosopher and psychologist, Franz Brentano.

Every mental phenomena or psychological act is referring to a certain intentional object. The intentional objects are the manifestation of psychological consciousness. This difference as being an intentional object and an intentional object will distinguish the physical and psychological activities. This argument is very important since the key point of experience is that it refers toward an object. The consciousness gained from experience is the consciousness of an intentional object.

In this essay, I will try to elaborate some theories dealing with the phenomenology of reading in which it tries to explain about how the readers gain meaning of a literary text. This theory is part of the reader-centered approach where the reader is the one who fold the meaning of a text. Writing as ‘grammata’–the writing form, printed form of literary or graphic mark of pages –is not the accomplished fact of meaning. Writing as ‘grammata’ is the potential of meaning and it is characterized as the phenomenological expectation of meaning and required to become the object of he readers’ consciousness, literary text will only b the phenomenological expectation of meaning of literary text. The act of reading is a mental process since the figure in the text will become imaginative figures in the readers’ mind.

According to Georges Poulet (1902-1991) a literary text is the combination between author’s consciousness and reader’s consciousness. Literary text is not only an object of a single subject but it belongs to two subjects, the author and the reader. This means that meaning of a literary text does not exist if it is only in a book without anybody reading it. The meaning of a literary text is modified by the reader’s consciousness from the first meaning which is folded by the author’s consciousness. He supported his argument further; that all books are as dead objects until someone reads them. The book needs the reader’s consciousness to exist. The existence of a book is not only in itself but also in the reader’s mind.

The reality of a literary text is gained from the reader’s consciousness. The way in which the reader tries to create the reality is a mental activity. When a reader reads a literary text, the figure of words, sentences, ideas, images of the text will become mental images in the reader’s mind. The way the reader interpret a literary text is influenced by the reader’s consciousness which they gain from their experiences. The interpretation of a reader will be different from others’ interpretation in interpreting the same text because everyone has different experiences which also make them to have different forms of consciousness. This difference also applied in the case that the reader would also give different interpretation from the author since they do not share the same experience.

Wolfgang Iser (1926- ) proposed that an important idea of indeterminacy where inside a literary text there are gaps and blanks which stimulate readers to construct meaning. Furthermore, he said that literary text is two-sided which are phenomenological and neumenonical. The first side of the literary text is that it is appear in the reader’s consciousness after the reader has the experience of reading the literary text and in the other side; literary text brings meaning in itself. In phenomenology, literary text brings in itself the guidelines, clues, specification, and cues to actualize as maximum meaning by reading the text.

Iser described three main points of analysis in his essay ‘The reading Process: A Phenomenological Approach’: the process of anticipation and retrospection, the consequent unfolding of a text as a living event, and the resultant impression of lifelikeness and these points of analysis will explain the relation between reader and text.

When a reader reads a literary text, the reader will reconstruct the world of the literary text by relating every sentence in the text to make a reasonable meaning in the reader’s consciousness. However, a reader cannot materialize the world in the literary text visually, he will visualize it in his imagination. Roman Ingarden (1893-1970) was the one who gives theory that reading is the concretization of meaning. Literary text is not autonomous in the meaning and it is not concrete, it depends on the readers. He argued that the world presented in a literary text is constructed out of intentionale Satzkorrelate (intentional sentence correlatives). Ingarden said that sentences linked up in different ways to form more complex units of meaning that reveal a very varied structure giving rise to such entities as a short story, a novel, a dialogue, a drama, etc.

While reading a literary text, a reader tries to relate a sentence to the next sentence. Through this process, a reader is able to fill he gaps which occur between sentences. The sentences in a literary text cannot fully concretize the visualization of the world in the literary text. In every literary text there is always a gap which should be fulfilled by the reader. If the author gives he full picture in his work, his work can be assume as a bad work of art since this kind of text will lead to boredom. The reader should be given spaces in literary text where they can create the world in their imagination. Their imagination is also part of their consciousness. Iser called the world presented after such act as the virtual dimension of the text. What the reader imagining in the act of reading is only the unwritten part of the text with the guidance of the written part. That is why if in a text there are no elements of indeterminacy, there are no gaps and blanks to fill, the reader will not be able to use their imagination to visualize the world in the literary text.

After reading a literary text, the meaning of the text will be absorbed by the reader’s memory and when the reader re-reads the text, his interpretation of the same text might be different. This thing happens because the reader already has the experience of the world in the literary text and it will effect their expectation in the second reading. The reader will be able to anticipate the relationship between ideas of the text and also there is a probability that the reader’s interpretation will be different because a text has potential of multiplicity interpretation. Meaning of a text is inexhaustible. The multi interpretation of a literary text will never exhaust its meaning. In the act of reading, the reader will connect the time sequence in the text. It will help them to construct the virtual dimension of the text. The process to build the virtual dimension of a text is a living process since the reader should continually try to relate one phrase to another in the text.

The text brings the nature of disturbance toward the reader’s expectation and this will lead to frustration of expectation of the reader. The disturbance can come in the flow of time sequence in the text. The reader will create different visualization of the literary world in every act of reading. The reader’s imagination will concretize this visualization by processing the information given in the literary text. The process of concretization of the meaning of literary text will lead the reader to form ‘gestalt’ of the text but ‘gestalt is not the true meaning of the literary text. ‘Gestalt’ is the result of the colliding of reader’s mind and the literary text. ‘Gestalt’ is merely a configurative meaning of the text.

The reader’s expectation upon the meaning of the literary text will lead them into illusion because he world presented in the literary text is not the true reality. This illusion appears because in interpreting a literary text, reader tend to restrict the polysemantics tendencies to have a valid form of the visualization because according to Wolfgang Iser, the polysemantics nature and the illusion making of the text are opposed factors. If the semantics factor of a text already fixed, then the illusion will be complete.

Read More......